If you know me well, you know that this is one of my least favourite times of the year. It’s complicated, so I’ll spare you the details. But It does seem to be tradition for blogs and newsletters to do a retrospective of the, soon to be over, year. It’s possibly something inherited from the traditional media industry. And whilst I’m not really a fan of this tradition —you can call me a miserable git for detesting the Spotify-like “wrapped” emails that have been invading and polluting my inbox and general use of apps. Please stop!— I thought it might be useful for me to have a look over some of the stuff I’ve been doing here this year. You don’t have to read this; please just click Mark as Read if it’s not your thing. I won’t judge.
I might take a break next week, so if you don’t see a new email next week, you’ll know why.
In the meantime, have a good holiday.
I started the new year with a new site (this one) with the intention of bringing all my writing and online presence into one place. The Substack “Nazi Bar” problem precipitated the move, and I needed to move off the bigger platforms onto something more independent and open that also had values around the open web.
I landed on micro.blog, a small company providing a simplified and highly customisable platform for blogging. It included newsletter capabilities (albeit rudimentary) and embraced federated technologies for authors to publish on other platforms. It has its own community and provides a social-like experience on a smaller and more manageable scale compared to standard social media (the Facebook’s and so on.)
Since then, I have posted exactly 60 articles, averaging one article a week in newsletter form and a couple of other posts about specific topics. I have been able to keep up a stable rhythm of writing and posting. I generally write starting on Sunday evening and finishing the article on Monday. Editing and proofreading are done on Monday evening so that I can post in the evening or early morning. I have been pretty consistent all year, although lately, I’ve been posting on Tuesday morning.
This post will be the 61st of the year, pushing the total number of words to over 50,000. Depending on who you ask, that is about the length of a book. It is on the lower end of the word count but book-length nonetheless.
In July, I started working with a small IT company on a part-time basis, and personally, I was worried that it would make it difficult for me to keep writing these articles. In the end, it worked out rather well, as it gave me a certain structure conducive to reading, researching, and writing a lot. I’m grateful to them for my employment. I’ve been continuing small contracts with other businesses, too, so the variety has been interesting and helped me keep my feet on the ground regarding what small businesses are living rather than the lofty ideals the media and tech companies often project. I can tell you they have literally no idea what is happening or what to do and are just happy to keep the money flowing through subscriptions, up-selling and cross-selling. The day a big firm really understands SMEs and does something for them, they’ll clean up.
This has been, loosely, the theme of this year’s writing: the disconnect and the disconnection of tech and society. A new word entered the dictionary, enshittification, to describe how businesses like Meta, Google, and plenty of others I have written about here have all turned a corner and are now actively making our online lives as hostile an environment as possible to maximise their profits.
I won’t re-litigate that here again; you can read a few of the posts I wrote here:
https://matthewcowen.org/archive/
I think the most significant topic I have concentrated on this year is Internet Governance.
I was in the ARIN Advisory Council election, and despite not getting elected, I didn’t disgrace myself. I look forward to being on the next list and continuing my involvement with ARIN. I hope we can do something with the French West Indies this year. I’d had initial talks, but time ran out. I’ll keep you posted.
I will continue to concentrate on this topic, and I’ll be looking to see if there are any employment opportunities in this space for someone like me who has many years of experience with the Internet and associated technologies and likes researching and writing about it. Please reach out if you know of anything.
I wrote a little about LLMs and had to admit defeat on the terminology. To re-iterate, LLMs (Large Language Models) like ChatGPT and the like are not Artificial Intelligence. Statistical next-word predictors are all they are. Impressive sometimes, yes, but absolutely useless most of the time. Unfortunately, that’s the conclusion that many are coming to now, as the rubber has hit the road. I’ll remind you of my experience in the Microsoft Copilot training, where the trainer used Copilot with a prompt that didn’t produce what was expected and then took a bunch of time to coax it into working, arguably spending more time than just doing the damn thing manually!
This year, I’ve tried to take a more pragmatic approach to discussion tech, Digital Transformation and the topics that seem to attract more smoke and mirrors discussion than real-world and practical analysis. I don’t think I’ve done an amazing job at that yet, but I think I’m definitely better at it than I was and probably better than a number of prominent tech journalists. To clarify, I’m not suggesting I’m a better journalist. I’m suggesting that I’m perhaps a little better at critical thinking about tech.
I hope to continue writing like this. I enjoy it, even if it is painful and cringe-inducing at times. I hope you’ve enjoyed reading it.
My ambitions for 2025 are to be more structured in my approach to articles. Next year, I plan to explore a topic in more detail, so maybe I should write a series of articles. Let me have a few glasses of Rhum over the holidays, and I’ll come back refreshed and ready to continue.
Thank you for reading, and I’ll be back in the new year.
Reading
My reading has only increased this year. I suspect next year will be no different. I have a ton on the backlog to read, and more is coming out daily.
Artificial Intelligence Isn’t Actually That Amazing - The reality can’t match the hype.
I think the title says it all. I’ll leave you to discover the short article. Just bear in mind that this is from an economist.
Dark Patterns in Cookie Banners: CNIL issues formal notice to website publishers
You may or may not like the cookie consent forms (which, by the way, exist because of the perverse interpretations from the ad tech industries of the requirements of EU regulation). Still, they try to move some control to you, the reader, rather than the ad tech industry. Well, they’re unhappy and not content enough with the already vast sums of minutiae about you and your life. They’re also sneaky bastards trying to trick you into clicking where you don’t want.
The “Sovereign Democratic Infrastructure” Hyperscalers Trick. Why We Shouldn’t Fall for It, and What We Should Do Instead
This is a very considered discussion of technology, sovereignty, data centres, and control. I’m not sure I agree with every point made, but I’m glad I read it.
European Union Member States Speak Up for Encryption
Noticeably absent… France, Spain, Belgium, Italy and others that should know better.
Enjoy your break if you have one, and have a great week.
